"Export all files" overwrites a former log file of that day

Dear all

I was in the outdoors this week with 2 SOTA activations which are both in the same POTA area. I usually export all log files at the end of the activation to my NAS at home. Doing so with the logfiles of the 2nd SOTA activation unfortunately overwrites the 1st file for the POTA area with the data of the 2nd file instead of saving both files separately to the NAS. There is no error message or warning for this conflict.

This problem is caused since Polo creates the same file name for the POTA file for both activations – it is the same POTA area. I suggest therefore to enhance the filenames by e.g. a timestamp or something convenient to prevent such an override in a 3rd party system. Or is there already a standard way to avoid this problem?

Thanks in advance and vy 73, Markus

You can put {{op.uuid}} in the Export Filename template

Alan

Hi Alan

Thanks for remembering me. Will try this.

However, I suggest to the team to discuss if the filename should not be enhanced by default to make it unique. One has to discover first that the next instance of the same POTA area overwrites the former one without any message. In dubio pro reo!

Vy 73, Markus

I understand the problem you ran into.

There’s no simple solution. If we add anything to the filenames, people will protest! trust me when I say that some people are very picky with what these filenames should be, and some programs even require very specific formats. Just adding a timestamp would raise protests.

And because on mobile operating systems, apps like PoLo have no direct access to the file system, we cannot inspect the directory to see if there is already a file with the same name.

A possible solution would be for PoLo to see if there is another operation at the same park in the same day, and use a name variation in that case. But because of how the export functionality is structured in the code, this is not trivial.

I’ll see what I can do, but no promises.

Dropbox warns of replacement and asks for a name change if so. So for Dropbox users, there is no real issue.

Alan